The legal consequences of CIS registration are of great importance for many entrepreneurs and private individuals. A registration in the Centraal Informatie Systeem (CIS) can have far-reaching effects on your business and private finances. In this article we extensively address what a CIS registration entails, which legal consequences are attached and which steps you can take to limit or remove any adverse effects. We also highlight various case law and provide practical tips for dealing with a negative registration.
What is a CIS registration?
A CIS registration is an entry in the Centraal Informatie Systeem, managed by Stichting CIS. It records information about non-payment, fraud or other incidents reported by insurers and credit providers. This system is used, among other things, by insurers to assess risks when concluding new policies or handling claims. CIS functions as a kind of warning system to limit fraud and defaults.
The registration contains data such as payment arrears, fraud cases and other incidents that may indicate an increased risk. The purpose of CIS is to protect insurers and financial institutions against undesirable risks so that they can better align premiums and terms with the risks presented by the customer. It is important to know that only relevant and verified data are included.
In addition to insurers, financial institutions such as banks and mortgage lenders also consult the Incident Register of CIS. As a result, a registration can affect creditworthiness and obtaining financing. The data are therefore used more broadly than just for insurance, which increases the impact of a registration.
Legal consequences of a CIS registration
The legal consequences of a CIS registration are significant. A report can lead to rejection of insurance applications, refusal of mortgage lending and even problems with banking services. Legally, the registration is considered processing of risk-related personal data under the AVG (Algemene Verordening Gegevensbescherming, the EU General Data Protection Regulation – GDPR), which means strict rules apply to the collection, storage and use of such data.
If you doubt the accuracy of a CIS registration, it is important first to establish which data have been recorded and by which insurer. Through an access request to Stichting CIS you can request your registrations.
In addition, an incorrect registration may give rise to claims for damages if the data subject can demonstrate that they suffered financial loss as a result. Legally, it is then important to demonstrate causality between the registration and the damage amount. Because this can be complex, it is advisable to seek legal assistance if you have doubts about your registration.
Effects on insurance
A CIS registration has direct consequences for insurance. Insurers use this information to determine premiums and decisions on acceptance. A negative registration can lead to higher premiums, refusal of coverage or even termination of existing policies. This can be particularly problematic for compulsory insurances, such as motor insurance.
A practical example: If you want to take out a damage insurance policy and you are registered because of a payment arrears at a previous insurer, the new insurer may view this as an increased risk and reject your application. This also applies to home insurance or liability insurance, where a negative registration can complicate acceptance or substantially increase the premium.
The consequences are not only financial but also legal. Insurers are obliged to ensure the accuracy of the recorded data. If you disagree with a registration, you have the right to object and, if necessary, start proceedings to have the registration removed. This is regulated in the policy conditions and the AVG. It is therefore crucial to check your data regularly and act promptly.
Impact on mortgages and banking
A CIS registration can also negatively affect your application for a mortgage or other banking products. Banks use CIS as part of their credit assessment. A negative registration can lead to rejection of a mortgage application or an increase in the interest rate, as it indicates an increased risk of default.
A concrete example is the refusal of a mortgage application because a previous payment arrears at an insurer is registered in the CIS. This can even occur if the arrears have since been resolved, because banks often also include historical data in their assessment. This can lead to long-lasting consequences, making it difficult to obtain financing.
Negative registrations can also have adverse effects for business bank accounts. For example, a bank may decide to limit services, request additional securities or charge higher fees. This can harm the continuity of your business. It is therefore wise to be alert to any CIS registrations in a business context as well.
Procedure for removing a CIS registration
If you have been registered in CIS incorrectly, it is important to act as quickly as possible. The first step is to submit a written objection to Stichting CIS, including all relevant evidence that proves the registration is incorrect. This may include proof of payment, correspondence with insurers or statements.
The foundation has a statutory period to respond to your objection. If they reject the objection, you can file a complaint with the Stichting Klachteninstituut Financiële Dienstverlening (Kifid) or initiate legal proceedings. Kifid can mediate and issue binding decisions in disputes between consumers and financial service providers.
In some cases it is advisable to engage a specialised lawyer experienced in removing EVR registrations and CIS matters. Such a lawyer can assist you in gathering evidence, drafting objections and conducting proceedings, which considerably increases the chance of success.
Checking a CIS registration
Stichting CIS states that the received registration is an exact representation of the data recorded in the CIS database. If you have questions about the reason for the registration or the information recorded, you can contact the insurer that placed the registration.
If the recorded information is incorrect in your view, you can contact the insurer directly or use the correction process of Stichting CIS. Stichting CIS forwards a correction request to the registering insurer; that insurer will amend or remove the data.
These steps help to carefully assess the specific registration and the available correction options. In case of doubt or disagreement, legal advice can help to evaluate your position and the relevant documents.
Practical tips for a negative CIS registration
Are you dealing with a negative CIS registration? It is important first to obtain an overview of the exact data that has been recorded. You can submit an access request to Stichting CIS to check which data about you are registered. This right of access is enshrined in the AVG and enables you to verify whether the data are correct and up to date.
Check the accuracy of the data and compare it with your administration. Are there errors or outdated reports? Gather evidence such as proof of payment, e-mails, letters and other correspondence to substantiate your objection. It is also wise to clearly note when and how you had contact with the insurer or credit provider.
In addition, it is sensible to obtain legal advice in a timely manner. A lawyer can help you draft an effective objection and, if necessary, start proceedings. This prevents prolonged financial and legal problems. You may also consider mediation or dispute resolution via the Incident Register or Kifid, which is often faster and less costly than litigation.
CIS registration: your rights and obligations
It is crucial to know your rights and obligations regarding a CIS registration. You have the right to access, correct and delete incorrect data. Stichting CIS is legally obliged to handle your data with care and to take your objection seriously. CIS must also limit the data to what is necessary and may not retain data longer than legally permitted.
Your obligations include paying premiums on time and informing your insurer correctly. Default or concealing important information can lead to registration and thus legal and financial consequences. Moreover, you must cooperate with communications and any investigations necessary to resolve a dispute about a registration.
For entrepreneurs, a CIS registration can also affect their business reputation and creditworthiness. This can, for example, lead to problems obtaining business credit or taking out insurance. Therefore, it is advisable to address any problems quickly and seek professional advice, for example via Arslan & Arslan Advocaten. Good legal guidance can prevent a negative registration from causing long-term damage.
Frequently asked questions
What can I do if I am wrongly registered in CIS?
You can submit a written objection to Stichting CIS with evidence proving that the registration is incorrect. If the objection is rejected, you can submit a complaint to Kifid or initiate legal proceedings. It is important to substantiate your objection well with concrete evidence and, if necessary, seek legal advice.
How long does a CIS registration remain?
A CIS registration generally remains for five years, unless you can demonstrate that the registration is incorrect or that the data must be removed due to exceptional circumstances. Sometimes exceptions can be made if the consequences of the registration are disproportionally severe.
Does a CIS registration affect my mortgage application?
Yes, banks use CIS data when assessing credit applications. A negative registration can lead to rejection or higher interest because it indicates an increased risk. It is therefore important to take timely action to limit adverse consequences in case of a negative registration.
Read also
- CIS registration: what is it and how do you remove it?
- EVR registration: difference with CIS explained
- CIS registration with insurers – what does it mean for you?
Need help?
Do you have questions about the legal consequences of CIS registration or do you want to have an incorrect registration removed? At Arslan & Arslan Advocaten we are ready to provide expert legal advice. Contact us for a free initial consultation and let us help you protect your rights.
Need help from a lawyer?
Contact our Rotterdam office or Amsterdam office for a free intake interview.
Need assistance? Our BKR lawyer will be happy to help you further. Contact us without obligation for a free first consultation.